Love Stories in Shades of Greene

By Candice Buchanan, Greene Connections Archivist

Originally published in Greene Speak in two parts, February 2005 and February 2006. Updated July 2020.

Here is an old favorite revived from our Greene Speak column series. Without their love stories, for better or worse, we would not be here today. Tell us, how did your ancestors meet?

Love at First Sight

Frances Cook was born in Greene County, Pennsylvania, in 1887, but moved as a young woman with her family to Columbiana, Ohio. Ties to Greene County remained strong. Frances returned often to visit friends and relatives. On one such occasion Frances sang with her hostess in the church choir. When John Madison Livingood caught sight of the musical guest, he turned to a friend and said, “I’m going to marry that girl.” They married 4 March 1914 in Columbiana, Ohio, then returned to Greene County to raise their family.

(Listen to their story, as told by their daughter, Sara (Livingood) Buchanan.)


  • Interview with Sara (Livingood) Buchanan, their daughter, 2003.
  • Columbiana County, Ohio, Marriage Book 23: 471, Livingood-Cook, 1914; Probate Court Office, Courthouse, Lisbon.

When They First Met

Joseph Warren Jacobs and Mary Emma (Dulaney) Jacobs on their wedding day, item no. JACB_AN001_0041, Helen Mae (Jacobs) Fonner Collection, shared by George and Anna (Fonner) Blystone, Greene Connections Archives Project.

Joseph Warren Jacobs is best known for his Purple Martin birdhouses and the incredible ornithology research that took him to World Fairs and made him a household name among birdwatchers. The talent that first introduced him to his wife-to-be, however, was his handwriting. J. Warren was hired to compose beautiful entries in the family Bibles of local residents. One such employer was Jasper Dulaney, whose daughter Mary Emma first met J. Warren during this task for her family. A young girl at the time, it was some years later while Emma was helping her father at his grocery store in Waynesburg, that J. Warren really made an impression on her. When J. Warren walked into the store, Emma was literally taken aback by his good looks. She stumbled backwards and fell into a bushel basket. Fortunately, J. Warren was the one to help her up. This memorable encounter, now as two adults, resulted in a wedding on 24 March 1897.


  • Interview with Anna (Fonner) Blystone, their granddaughter, 2005.
  • Greene County, Pennsylvania, Marriage License Docket 7: 106, Jacobs-Dulaney, 1897; County Clerk’s Office, Courthouse, Waynesburg.

Weddings Gone Wrong

Sarah Elizabeth “Lizzie” (Bryan) (Garard) Loller, item no. GCHS-AN008-0014, Inghram-Lindsey Album 06, Photo 14, Greene County Historical Society Collection, Greene Connections Archives Project.

Nineteen-year-old Sarah Elizabeth Bryan of Richhill Township, best known as Lizzie to her friends and family, was described as “a rather good looking, sprightly young woman.” In September 1871, she completed her coursework at Waynesburg College, becoming one of the school’s early female graduates. That same month, Lizzie attended the wedding of some friends, in the company of another Waynesburg College student, James Corbly Garard. Though Mr. Garard was not her father’s favorite suitor, Lizzie and Corbly stood up after their friends that day to make secret wedding vows before Rev. Campbell Jobes and the audience present. In those days, Pennsylvania did not require marriage licenses, so there was nothing to prevent or delay their nuptials. The ceremony kept quiet; Lizzie returned home to her father’s house.

Over the next several months, Silas Loller, a music professor at Waynesburg College, became a frequent caller at the Bryan home. Knowing no better and having the approval of her parents, Silas proposed to Lizzie, was accepted, and by April 1872 they were husband and wife. About two weeks after their wedding day, Silas and Lizzie were at her parents’ home, when they were called on by Mr. Garard. Lizzie’s father refused to let the young man in, but after several failed attempts, Corbly demanded his right to speak to his “lawfully wedded wife.” Only Lizzie was not shocked.

Silas immediately went to Waynesburg to seek legal counsel, but he found little relief. Lizzie’s “youth and impulsive nature” were blamed for her marriage to Corbly, which she alleged to be only a joke. The law failed to find the humor. Corbly and Lizzie were legally divorced 8 January 1877 by the Greene County court. Presumably, the Lollers were then legally remarried because they appear as a family in subsequent records and are buried together in the Bryan Cemetery in Center Township.


  • “Twice at the Altar” article, Waynesburg Republican, Waynesburg, Pennsylvania, 10 April 1872, page 3, column 1.
  • Greene County, Pennsylvania Appearance Docket 33: 580 (continued 33: 590), item no. 458, J. C. Garard vs. Elizabeth Garard, divorce, October 1876 term; Prothonotary’s Office, Courthouse, Waynesburg.
  • Elizabeth Bryan Loller obituary, Waynesburg Republican, Waynesburg, Pennsylvania, 10 August 1911, page 4, column 6
  • Candice Buchanan, “The Early Coeducational Institution as Matchmaker: A Study of Romantic Attachments at Waynesburg College 1850-1875,” Western Pennsylvania History, volume 91 (Fall 2008): 46-57.

A Civil War Soldier Finds His Match

“Adams-Robinson December 10, 1876, in Beverly, Ohio, by Rev. Chapman, Mr. Robert Adams, of Leavenworth, Kas., to Miss Mary Robinson, of the former place….Robert is a son of Mr. Elijah Adams, steward of the Poor House, and the bride is a graduate of Waynesburg College, a bright and intelligent lady. Robert carries an empty coat sleeve, having lost an arm at Fredericksburg, but he now has two arms for the one he lost. May their arms never be less.”

Sadly, Mary did not live to celebrate her first wedding anniversary. Robert later remarried another Waynesburg College graduate, Martha Paull Wells, Class of 1871, with whom he rests in Arlington National Cemetery.


  • Adams-Robinson marriage announcement article, Waynesburg Republican, Waynesburg, Pennsylvania, 17 January 1877, page 3, column 6.
  • Ohio, County Marriages, 1789-2013, database with images, FamilySearch, Robert Adams – Mary M. Robinson, 19 December 1876, Washington County license no. 4894, FHL microfilm 941959; Ohio County Courthouses.
  • Mary Robinson Adams obituary, Waynesburg Republican, Waynesburg, Pennsylvania, 24 October 1877, page 3, column 3.
  • Robert Adams obituary, Waynesburg Republican, Waynesburg, Pennsylvania, 1 October 1914, page 4, column 6.

Thrown Together

William Roy Buchanan and his wife, Sara (Livingood) Buchanan, item no. CAND_AN004_0067, Candice Lynn Buchanan Collection, Greene Connections Archives Project.

Roy Buchanan and Sara Livingood were classmates at Center Township Vocational High School in the early 1930s. During their junior or senior year, the class sold subscriptions to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, earning a trip to Pittsburgh. The day was very eventful, a tour of Heinz factory that included lunch, a visit to a music conservatory, a flower show, sightseeing at the recently constructed Cathedral of Learning at Pittsburgh University, and finally a movie called Mystery of the Wax Museum in which wax figures came to life. Despite the full schedule, Sara always told that the excitement really began on the ride home. The small country school had managed to provide two buses to transport the students between Rogersville and Pittsburgh. On the return trip the bus Roy was on broke down and the displaced students squeezed onto Sara’s bus. Sara consequently rode home sitting on Roy’s lap. According to Sara, they both “kinda liked it!” They graduated together in 1934 and were married in 1938 after Sara graduated from Waynesburg College.

(Listen to their story, as told by Sara (Livingood) Buchanan.)


  • Interview with Sara (Livingood) Buchanan, 2003.
  • Greene County, Pennsylvania, Marriage License Docket 25: 228, Buchanan-Livingood, 1938; Office of the Orphans’ Court, Greene County Courthouse, Waynesburg.

Parental Consent Not Required

Sarah (Throckmorton) Milligan, Waynesburg College, Class of 1860, item no. WAYN_AN001_1860_0003, Waynesburg University Paul R. Stewart Museum Collection, Greene Connections Archives Project.

Sarah Throckmorton [1836-1897] was the daughter of Morford Throckmorton [1792-1884] and his second wife, Nancy Simpson [1801-1869]. Morford was a blacksmith and farmer who migrated to Greene County from New Jersey as a young man around 1812. Sarah was the only one of Morford’s six daughters to graduate from Waynesburg College, though her younger sister Caroline did attend during the 1860/61 school year – an education which coincidentally ended at the same time that Sarah’s secret marriage was revealed. The rebellious attachment Sarah formed while at school is outlined in the family history:

“Sarah Throckmorton was a decidedly attractive girl of much more than ordinary intellectuality. Her laugh lay very near her lips, and to her keen sense of humor she added a gift of putting amusing things in words that made her merry company. Among her many ardent admirers was Joseph M. Milligan, a handsome, witty young student of Irish descent – courteous in manner, entertaining in conversation, a sweet singer, but poor in purse. They became engaged, but the engagement met with opposition from the young lady’s parents. So, they hied themselves to the Waynesburg M. E. Parsonage and were secretly married by Rev. M. J. Pierce, 15 August 1861. Several weeks later, during the minister’s vacation, two students glancing over his books discovered the marriage record and noised it abroad. Mrs. Throckmorton, while shopping in Waynesburg, heard the report and was properly scandalized. Hurrying home, the lively Sarah was promptly interviewed, and then and there received such a severe, old-fashioned Puritanic scolding that the memory lingered long, and surreptitious marriages were never popular among her descendants.”

Joseph M. Milligan, Waynesburg College, Class of 1861, item no. WAYN_AN001_1861_0006, Waynesburg University Paul R. Stewart Museum Collection, Greene Connections Archives Project.

After Joseph’s graduation in 1861, the couple moved to Washington County, Pennsylvania, and in 1869 to Afton, Iowa. Whatever the objections to Joseph were, he became a successful school administrator and lawyer. He and Sarah lived in Iowa until their deaths and raised five children.


  • Mofford Throckmorton obituary, Waynesburg Republican, Waynesburg, Pennsylvania, 22 January 1884, page 3, column 5.
  • Frances Grimes Sitherwood, Throckmorton Family History: Being the Record of the Throckmortons in the United States of America with Cognate Branches (Bloomington, Illinois: Pantagraph Printing & Stationary Co., 1929), 178.
  • Sarah Throckmorton Milligan and Joseph M. Milligan Matriculation Cards, Waynesburg College classes of 1860 and 1861 respectively, on file at the Waynesburg University Office of Institutional Advancement.
  • Candice Buchanan, “The Early Coeducational Institution as Matchmaker: A Study of Romantic Attachments at Waynesburg College 1850-1875,” Western Pennsylvania History, volume 91 (Fall 2008): 46-57.

Love Me as I Am

“Thomas Dale Watts, tall, dark wavy hair, brown eyes and the son of a preacher man, met Ruth Aldene Hughes, very attractive, blue eyes, beautiful smile and the stepdaughter of a farmer. It was love at first sight. He had brought his mother, Minnie to the farm to buy milk. Ruth was ironing and her mother Bertha told her to wash her face and comb her hair because the preacher’s wife and son had come. She told her mother, she really didn’t care, she wasn’t wanting to impress anyone. So, the story goes and the following December, they announced their engagement. On 26 June 1937 they were married in the Kuhntown Methodist Church. Dale’s father Rev. Watts solemnized a large wedding with several attendants, who had made their own gowns and bouquets.”


For more fun, scroll through the documents and photographs tagged WEDDING in the Greene Connections Archives.

4 Comments on “Love Stories in Shades of Greene

  1. Just a great piece. We will have to work at expanding this collection as the topic of “how did they meet” should be able to provide near endless and interesting content now and for generations to come.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. My parents met in college. As a part of my father’s athletic scholarship he was required to serve tables in the student cafeteria. The seats and tables were assigned to the students so my father would consistently be serving the same students at his tables. My mother happened to be one of the students assigned to his tables and he took a particular fancy to her. As an expression of his “affection” he would always trade out the standard silverware setting at my mother’s place with an oversized knife, fork and spoon that were normally used by the cook back in the kitchen in preparation of the bulk quantities of food. This special attention to my mother did not go unnoticed and served as the basis for how their relationship blossomed into 50+ years together.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: